Friday, February 26, 2010

Judge Allows Ozzy Osbourne to Continue Lawsuit Over BLACK SABBATH

Back in June 2009, I wrote (link here) about the lawsuit filed by Ozzy Osborne against Tony Iommi over the rights to the BLACK SABBATH name. Ozzy’s lawsuit sought a declaration that he is at least a joint owner of the BLACK SABBATH mark (after rejoining the band in 1997 and revitalizing the brand) and that Iommi is not the sole owner of the mark as well as a cancellation of the BLACK SABBATH federal registration that Iommi currently owns on the basis that Iommi, when he filed the application in March 1999, made a knowingly false statement to the PTO when he declared that no other person had any right to use the BLACK SABBATH mark in commerce.

Today, the New York Post reported that District Court Judge John Koeltl ruled in favor of allowing Ozzy to move forward with his suit – while at the same time urging the parties to resume mediation in order to resolve the case instead of proceeding to trial. No other details have been reported. Other coverage by Blabbermouth.net.

So it looks like the Iron Man will Rock On.

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Google – the real profiteer of “typosquatting”

An article in NewScientist.com highlights a report done by two Harvard University Professors entitled “Measuring the Perpetrators and Funders of Typosquatting” which analyzes the profitability of “typosquatting.”

Of course, the not-so-surprising finding from the study is that Google may be earning almost $500 million per year from domain name registrants who engage in so-called “typosquatting” who then post pay-per-click (“PPC”) ads generated by Google.

The report found that nearly 80% of the typosquatting domains showed pay-per-click advertisements that came from ad platforms operated by Google and Yahoo, which leads the authors to make the following suggestion to help with “typosquatting”:

Because ad platforms are the primary or sole source of revenue for these typo domains, we believe ad platforms are well-positioned to substantially reduce typosquatting. Among other responses, ad platforms could select partners more carefully, select only partners with a demonstrated record of avoiding typosquatting, and/or sever ties to partners who are found to engage in typosquatting. Furthermore, ad platforms could require that new partners showing ads on many domains post a bond that is forfeited upon typosquatting, or deduct penalties from payments to any partners found to engage in typosquatting. To the best of our knowledge, ad platforms have taken none of these steps.

The report did disclose that one of the authors of the study is also co-counsel in the pending lawsuit that Vulcan Golf filed against Google back in 2007 arising from Google earning money from typosquatting domains. (A similar report by was highlighed in a October 2008 article on wired.com discussing the pending lawsuit against Google).

And while the report notes Google’s disavowance of any involvement or responsibility over the registration and use of typosquatting domains, the report states the following regarding why search engines such as Google should (and indeed can) take on more responsibility to help alleviate the problem at their end – rather than forcing trademark owners to go after individual domain name registrants of typosquatting domains:

Despite the simplication resulting from ad platforms' preferred approach, we see multiple problems with ad platforms disclaiming all responsibility for the typosquatting they fund. For one, our analysis confirms that payments from ad platforms are the sole force behind most typosquatting registrations. Further- more, ad platforms are least-cost avoiders -- able to prevent typosquatting with less effort than any other party. In particular, thanks to the semantic analysis capabilities and spelling correction skills search engines gained through their principal businesses, ad platforms are well equipped to identify typosquatting registrations. (Consider Google's well-known and strikingly accurate “Did you mean?" function.) Indeed, search engines already receive information about the domains users visit (necessary to target ads accordingly). It would be straightforward to compare these requests to a list of top trademarks, and disallow parking ads from appearing on domains that are misspellings of popular sites.

But what I would really like someone to study is who are the internet browsers who travel to these typosquatting domains filled with PPC advertising after typing in the wrong domain name (and who were purportedly looking for a particular site – after all, how would there be a typo to squat upon) and who click on these PPC links instead of just bringing up one of the major search engines to find the site for which you were looking? The report explains how these sites make money (and Google’s important contribution to the business model) – but what I want to know is in the age of more enlightened understanding regarding navigating cyberspace, why do these sites make money?

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Battle Lines Drawn Between City of Las Vegas and Clark County over rights to .VEGAS top-level domain

I previously blogged (link here) about the efforts by the City of Las Vegas to partner with local company, Dot Vegas Inc. (“Dot Vegas”), over the creation of a new top-level-domain (“TLD”) — .VEGAS (a new domain name address suffix that could be used instead of the more common TLDs of .COM, .ORG, or .NET). The City of Las Vegas chose Dot Vegas over The Greenspun Corporation, owner of VEGAS.COM, which had also expressed interest in being the provider of the .VEGAS TLD. The same post also highlighted the potential conflict looming between the City of Las Vegas and Clark County over who should be the only “governmental municipality” in “Vegas” benefiting from registrations of .VEGAS domain names. After all, most of the hotel and casinos that outsiders with “Vegas” (including “The Strip”) is technically in the unincorporated area of Clark County and not within the City of Las Vegas.

I guess “Welcome to Fabulous Clark County, Nevada” doesn't have the same ring to it.

As reported today by The Las Vegas Review Journal (updated article here), Clark County commissioners voted today to endorse Vegas.com’s bid to be the provider of the .VEGAS TLD, thus setting up the battle between the City of Las Vegas and Clark County over who has the superior rights to the term VEGAS. Vegas.com has offered to pay the County $1.50 for every address registered under .VEGAS or 10 percent of the gross revenue, whichever is greater (in contrast, Dot Vegas’ deal with the City of Las Vegas was for 75 cents per registration or 10 percent of the gross revenues from future registrations).

Once final rules are established by ICANN over these new custom TLDs (information and announcements on ICANN’s gTLD program can be found here) and assuming both companies move forward with their plans, the battle will move on to ICANN which will have to determine which “governmental municipality” has the superior rights to “Vegas.”

[02/17/10 Update: The Las Vegas Sun also published an article on the controversy].

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Article spotlights partnership and conflict over .VEGAS top-level-domain

The Las Vegas Sun ran a story yesterday (link here) regarding the efforts of the City of Las Vegas to enter into a partnership with a local company, Dot Vegas Inc. (“Dot Vegas”), over the creation of a new top-level-domain (“TLD”) — .VEGAS (a new domain name address suffix that could be used instead of the more common TLDs of .COM, .ORG, or .NET). Dot Vegas is proposing that the City of Las Vegas get 75 cents per registration or 10 percent of the gross revenues from future registrations.


But another player in the picture is The Greenspun Corporation which owns VEGAS.COM (along with numerous Section 2(f)-based trademark registrations for the domain name as mark) and which has also been evaluating the business prospects behind a .VEGAS TLD ever since ICAAN announced in 2008 that it would allow the creation of custom TLDs. The CEO of Vegas.com reportedly was prepared to enter into a partnership for $1 per registration.



“The Strip” . . . in Fabulous Clark County, Nevada

Further complicating the matter is the “Vegas” governmental municipality with the authority to be involved in (and receive the benefits of) the .VEGAS TLD. After all, while most local Las Vegas residents recognize and understand the distinction between the incorporated City of Las Vegas and the unincorporated area of Clark County, Nevada, most outsiders may not realize that most of what the public identifies as Las Vegas, including “The Strip” (the area most often associated by the public with “Las Vegas”) is technically in the unincorporated area of Clark County and not within the City of Las Vegas. This has certain Clark County officials raising questions about whether the City of Las Vegas should be the only “governmental municipality” in “Vegas” benefiting from registrations of .VEGAS domain names.

For now, while the possible partnerships and conflicts over the creation of a .VEGAS TLD make for interesting news articles (and blog posts), such talk is somewhat premature (to paraphrase the MarkMonitor.com representative quoted in the Sun article) given that ICANN has yet to issue final rules regarding applications for such customized top-level domain names. Information and announcements on ICANN’s gTLD program can be found here.

[Update 2/4/10: Both the Las Vegas Sun and the Las Vegas Review Journal ran articles today reporting on the Las Vegas City Council's vote to endorse Dot Vegas' plans for a .VEGAS TLD.]

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Senator Leahy (D-VT) Introduces Trademark Legislation and Decries Trademark Bullies



According to a press release from Senator Patrick Leahy’s office, the Senator is introducing a bill entitled The Trademark Law Technical and Conforming Amendment Act Of 2010 (S. 2968).

The legislation purports to make some technical and confirming amendments to U.S. trademark lawsuit to help improve the efficiency of United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), including allowing applicants to correct good faith and harmless errors.

More interesting, however, is the requirement in the legislation for the Department of Commerce to study whether large corporations are misusing the trademark laws to harass small businesses by exaggerating the scope of their trademark protection and to report to Congress on any suggested policy changes to protect small businesses. Leahy’s press release statement focused on a particular dispute where Hansen Beverage Co., the maker of the Monster energy drink, sued Rock Art Brewery, a small microbrewery in Morrisville, Vermont (the state that Leahy represents) over its use of the name “The Vermonster” for one of its microbrews (news articles on the dispute here and here):

This legislation also requires a study of how the current system can better protect small businesses from abuses of the trademark system by larger corporations. Congress provides strong enforcement tools to intellectual property owners, as we should, to deter infringing activity and to remove counterfeit products from the market. I have become concerned, however, that large corporations are at times abusing the substantial rights Congress has granted them in their intellectual property to the detriment of small businesses. In fact, we saw a high-profile case like this in Vermont last year involving a spurious claim against Rock Art Brewery in Morrisville. When a corporation exaggerates the scope of its rights far beyond a reasonable interpretation in an attempt to bully a small business out of the market, that is wrong. This legislation therefore directs the Secretary of Commerce, in coordination with the Intellectual Property Enforcement Coordinator, to consider options for protecting small businesses from such harassing litigation, while ensuring that legitimate trademark infringement actions are handled efficiently and expeditiously by the courts.

For a related story involving a different “Monster,” check out these prior blog posts here and here.
[The TTABlog® describes one of the conforming changes made by the legislation to make the renewal deadlines (and grace periods) for trademarks protected in accordance with the Madrid Protocol consistent with the renewal deadlines (and grace periods) of other registered trademarks.]

Monday, January 18, 2010

Busy Busy Busy....

What’s a blogger to do when too busy to post something original – cite to other interesting blog posts, of course.



Seattle Trademark Lawyer Michael Atkins, posting a follow-up related to a declaratory judgment action for noninfringement of alleged trade dress filed by language software company Topics Entertainment Inc. against Rosetta Stone Ltd., provides a lesson about the “first to file” rule of which every lawyer should take note.



Courthousenews posts on the lawsuit filed by Mine O’Mine, Inc. (the corporation which owns the rights of publicity and intellectual property of Shaquille O’Neal) in Nevada District Court over a clothing company’s use of SHAQTUS (a moniker ascribed to O’Neil after he was traded to the Phoenix Suns and was called “The Big Shaqtus” – a play on the name Shaq and the many cacti prevalent in Arizona). See Mine O'Mine, Inc. v. Michael Calmese, True Fan Logo, Inc. and Dan Mortense, Case No. 10-cv-00043 (D. Nev. January 12, 2010) (complaint here). The Las Vegas Sun also ran a story on the lawsuit (link here).



Onpointnews discusses “The South Butt” case and the “cheeky” answer filed by Jimmy Winkleman’s attorneys in response to the trademark infringement lawsuit filed by the owners of The North Face clothing line that seeks to test the bounds of parody protection (and probably making more light of a matter that Mr. Winkleman should probably be taking much more seriously).



Pittsbrgh Trademark Lawyer Dan Corbett posts on the latest lawsuit filed by my favorite litigious cookie company, Eat ‘N Park Hospitality Group, Inc. (prior posts here and here) who maintains that its Section 2(f) trademark registration gives it a monopoly on a smiley face design on a cookie.

While Eat N’ Park has mostly gone after smaller online cookie sellers (and no doubt, convinced many of them to enter into a license agreement rather than continue with a costly litigation fight), it looks like Eat N’ park is finally going after a competitor, Crumbs Corporation, that actually has some money to fight. As discussed in my prior post here (discussing the setback faced by Franklin Loufrani’s SmileyWorld at the TTAB),

[G]iven that it took a “truly impressive” amount of money for Wal-Mart to stake a claim on a “ubiquitous, non-inherently distinctive design” that has become a “common feature of modern American culture,” one wonders if Eat ‘N Park can continue to claim exclusive rights to its “smiley” cookies when most (if not all) of Eat ‘N Park’s defendants are merely decorating a cookie with that captures this famed ornamental symbol.Does anybody out there really think that Eat ‘N Park has the same “impressive” advertising dollars to back up its claim of acquired distinctiveness? As the TTAB stated “Considering that we have already determined that the smiling face is a common feature of modern American culture, [acquired distinctiveness] will not be something easily achieved."

Finally, Ron Coleman’s Likelihood of Confusion® dispenses some detailed advice to an unnamed attorney with a client looking to establish a brand around the title or other reference that suggests a particular famous movie or scene therefrom. The cartoonish figure pictured above dispenses some of the most detailed and insightful free legal advice I’ve read online in a long time.

Friday, January 8, 2010

Minnesota Indian Casino Sues Local Henderson Casino Over MYSTIC name

Mystic Lake Casino Hotel in Minnesota


Las Vegas Sun reporter Steve Green reports on the trademark infringement lawsuit filed in Nevada District Court by the Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux Community (“Shakopee”) against Templeton Gaming Corporation (“Templeton”) and its owner Hugh Templeton (link to story here) [I am quoted in the article]. See Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux Community v. Templeton Gaming Corporation et al., Case No. 10-cv-00010 (D. Nev). A copy of the complaint can be viewed here.

Shakopee owns the Mystic Lake Casino Hotel in Scott County, Minnesota (near Minneapolis). Templeton owns a local video poker bar in Henderson, Nevada going by the name Mystic Lodge Casino.

Mystic Lodge Casino in Henderson, Nevada

While Shakopee appears to promote its services primarily using the mark MYSTIC LAKE, it also happens to own a trademark registration for the word mark MYSTIC in connection with “entertainment services, namely providing casino facilities” registered January 6, 1998. While Shakopee also owns numerous other registrations containing the word MYSTIC in connection with goods and services related to its casino/hotel operations (a “family of marks” as Shakopee would likely describe it), this single registration alone gives Shakopee some strong ammunition against companies that wish to use the word MYSTIC in connection with a casino related business.

While Shakopee appears to have the upper hand in making a legal argument against Templeton for likelihood of confusion based on the Sleekcraft factors, all I could think about with this case was that it looked like a “Dawn Donut” situation. See Dawn Donut Co., Inc. v. Hart’s Food Stores, Inc., 267 F.2d 358 (2d Cir. 1959). As described recently by the Nevada district court in Kerzner Int'l, Inc. v. Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc., 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 116622 (D. Nev. December 14, 2009) (blog post here):

Under the Dawn Donut rule, even if a federal registrant has rights in a mark, it is not necessarily entitled to an injunction against an unauthorized user: “if the use of the marks by the registrant and the unauthorized user are confined to two sufficiently distinct and geographically separate markets, with no likelihood that the registrant will expand his use into the defendant’s market, so that no public confusion is possible, then the registrant is not entitled to enjoin the junior user’s use of the mark.” Dawn Donut, 267 F.2d at 364 (footnote omitted); see also Fairway Foods, Inc. v. Fairway Markets, Inc., 227 F.2d 193, 198 (9th Cir. 1955) (vacating injunction issued to prevailing plaintiff on essentially the same basis as later became known as the Dawn Donut rule). Only once the federal registrant has expanded its use of the mark, so that the market areas of the two users are no longer separate and distinct, will the registrant be entitled to an injunction. Mister Donut of Am., Inc. v. Mr. Donut, Inc., 418 F.2d 838, 844 (9th Cir. 1969) (citing Dawn Donut).

Given that the tribe’s operation of its casino is certainly bound by its Indian territory boundaries and not likely to expand its use of the Mystic mark into the into the Henderson, Nevada area where this small locals casino operates, should Shakopee be allowed to stop them from using the name until such time as Shakopee expands into the Las Vegas market?

Of course, any discussion of “Dawn Donut” would not be complete without raising the issue of whether in this day and age of nationwide commerce through the Internet, whether “Dawn Donut” is relevant any more. The following are two excellent articles focusing on this particular issue:

Indeed, Shakopee's argument would certainly be that while its casino business is limited to its tribal area in Minnesota, its reputation (thanks to its traditional and Internet marketing) is nationwide and thus, consumers visiting the Henderson, Nevada area who come across this locals place may believe that there is an affiliation between this "Mystic Lodge Casino" and that other "Mystic" casino in Minnesota with which they are familiar or about which they have heard.